Canada’s Supreme Court Declares That Poking a Hole in Condom and Getting Girlfriend Pregnant Constitute Sexual Assault
By Vittorio Hernandez | March 10, 2014 1:32 AM EST
REUTERS/Soe Zeya Tun
A man sells condoms on Feb. 18 in Yangon, Myanmar. Even as a national debate rages over contraception insurance, tens of thousands of low-income women and teenagers across the United States have lost access to subsidized birth control as states slash and restructure family-planning funds.
Poking a hole in a condom and getting the girlfriend pregnant because of the prank is considered a form of sexual assault, the Supreme Court of Canada ruled on Friday.
With the decision, the court dismissed the appeal by Nova Scotia resident Craig Jaret Hutchinson who was given an 18-month sentence in December 2011 and placed on the national sex offender registry. He had admitted that he damaged the condom of his girlfriend so she would become pregnant and not split from him.
Seven justices said that Mr Hutchinson's acts of sabotaging the condom exposed his girlfriend to higher risk of pregnancy and is fraud. There was lack of consent to pregnancy because of his fraudulent action.
However, three other justices said it was not a question of the girlfriend's consent invalidated by the fraud he committed, but if she consented to how their sex had taken place.
The girlfriend had insisted she did not want to become pregnant, but because of the holes in the condom, she became pregnant. But their relationship still ended after he admitted in text messages of his sabotage. She eventually got an abortion which caused her to suffer from uterine infection.
Luke Craggs, the lawyer of Mr Hutchinson, said that while they were disappointed by the court decision, the ruling placed a closure on the issue.
"I don't know if there are going to be any other cases like this. It's not every day that we normally hear about someone sabotaging the birth control that a woman was counting on," CBC quoted the lawyer.
The court had previously ruled that not disclosing one's marital status to a partner is only deception, but not strong enough to lead to a sex assault conviction. Even failure to disclosed HIV status is not ground for a sexual assault conviction if the risk of transmission is low.
The landmark decision, penned by Chief Justice Beverly McLachlin and Justice Thomas Cromwell, said, "A person consents to how she will be touched, and she is entitled to decide what sexual activity she agrees to engage in for whatever reason she wishes. The fact that some of the consequences of her motives are more serious than others, such as pregnancy, does not in the slightest undermine her right to decide how the sexual activity she chooses to engage in is carried out. It is neither her partner's business not the state's."
To contact the editor, e-mail:
Most Popular Slideshows
- Kate Middleton Suffocated in Kensington Palace, Queen Elizabeth Reported War With The Duchess [PHOTOS]
- Chris Martin Dating Reports: Jennifer Lawrence Vs Gwyneth Paltrow [PHOTOS]
- 2014 MTV Video Music Awards: Everything To Know [PHOTOS]
- British Style Icon Kate Middleton Fashion Talk With Camilla Parker-Bowles Daughter-In-Law [PHOTOS]
Join the Conversation
- Woman Accuses Labor Leader of 1986 Rape When She was 16; Shorten Admits Being Probed But Says He Was Cleared
- Sydney Fashion Designer Jodhi Meares’ Driver License Suspended for Drunk-Driving
- Intelligence Agencies Hunt for James Foley Beheader Using Voice Recognition Technology, Journalist Was Warned by GlobalPost Editor Not to Go to Libya
- Boxing News 2014: Pacquiao KOs Philippine Taxman as Supreme Court Stops Agency from Requiring P4.2 Billion Surety Bond from Champ
- British PM David Cameron Cuts Short Summer Holiday to Lead Hunt for Foley Beheader; Abbott Calls Decapitation ‘Pure Evil’
- James Foley Beheading Video Has Play-Acting Portions – Video Experts Say
- 4.7-Inch, 5.5-Inch iPhone 6 Models Confirmed with Similar Build, Cam Features & 300+ Screen Pixels on Release Date
- Apple iPhone 6 Release Date, iPhone 6C or 6L Anticipation: Three Things Should Matter To New Phone Shoppers
- Xiaomi Mi4 vs iPhone 6: Why Forecasts Favor Mi4 as The Next Best Phone Against iPhone 6
- James Foley: More Chilling Information Revealed By Escaped Journalists
- Companies Push Back IPO Plans Due to Mega Alibaba Share Launch
- Samsung Galaxy Note 4 Release Date Update: 4 Feature Upgrades That Really Matter