FDI In Indian Retail: Minister Says Gov't Confident Of Parliamentary Support
By Angelo Young | November 29, 2012 6:11 AM EST
India has been grappling for months over the executive branch's recent decision to let the country’s 28 states decide for themselves whether multi-brand retailers that are majority owned by foreign companies may conduct business in their biggest cities.
The administration of Manmohan Singh decreed in September that India's state governments may decide on their own whether to let in multi-brand retailers 51 percent owned by foreign companies like Wal-Mart Stores Inc. (NYSE: WMT), France’s grocery store chain Carrefour SA (EPA: CA) operate under local minority stake partnerships. Earlier this year the government opened the way for single-brand retailers, such as Reebok, to operate stores in which they hold 100 percent ownership.
The September decree on foreign direct investment (FDI) requires such multi-brand retailers to source 30 percent of their goods from India and commit to building permanent infrastructure, such as cold storage facilities that India needs to reduce the waste of fruits and vegetables that spoil before they reach shelves.
The September decision has sharply divided the nation. So far, five of 28 Indian states and the capital New Delhi have approved allowing FDI in retail. Of them, Maharashtra, the western state with Mumbai as its capital, has 11 cities with more than 100,000 people.
However, the FDI decision also sparked strong criticism from the nation's second-largest party, the nationalist Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), which is worried that the arrival of large multi-national retail companies could put smaller Indian rivals out of business.
"BJP has decided very firmly and there will be no compromise...we want a discussion that ends with a vote in Lok Sabha,” the head of BJP Sushma Swaraj said, according to NDTV. The Lok Sabha is the Indian version of the U.S. House of Representatives.
The BJP is supported in its opposition to easing India's FDI policies by some left-wing parties.
"We will continue our opposition against FDI in retail. If the voting takes place on FDI in Parliament, then we will vote against it," said Gurudas Dasgupta, an MP of the Communist Party of India, according to a report Tuesday in Outlook India.
In a bid to reverse the September decision, the BJP and its allies have been demanding a vote in Parliament on the decision, but Singh's coalition initially said it did not need Parliamentary approval to ease the nation's foreign direct investment policy. However, the government now says it is willing to let Parliament vote on the decision, expressing confidence that it has enough votes to prevail on the issue.
"From day one I have said we have the numbers," Kamal Nath, minister of parliamentary affairs, said to The Times of India, following a meeting Wednesday with opposition leaders of both houses of Parliament. He rejected the suggestion by a reporter that his confidence was invigorated after a minority party in parliament – the Dravidian Progress Federation – recently said it supported the September decision.
The issue is a contentious one that could see some Indian cities receiving multi-brand retailers like Wal-Mart.
India’s retail sector is expanding quickly. In 2007 it represented about 15 percent of gross domestic product, worth about half-trillion dollars a year. As India's middle class develops, consumers are expected increasingly to spend proportionately less on the traditional family owned shops, especially in the countries urban centers like Mumbai, the nation's financial hub.
To contact the editor, e-mail:
Most Popular Slideshows
- Taylor Swift Named Forbes' Second Highest Paid Country Musician [PHOTOS]
- Forever Lost: Indescribable Anguish for Malaysia Airlines MH17 Families, Remains of Some Victims May Never Be Found (PHOTOS)
- Global Aviation Accidents: UN to Form Safety Task Force, Gov'ts Should Share Intelligence Info to Avert Future Incidents on Flying Over Warzones (PHOTOS)
- Lunch with the Gods: Pope Francis Eats with Vatican Workers in Cafeteria
Join the Conversation
- Toyota Tops World Sales of Cars, Sells Over 5K Million Vehicles in First Half of 2014
- Man Swindles Apple for $309,768 in 16 States
- Texas Man Selling Condo With ‘Funniest and Most Revealing Ad’
- Air New Zealand Pays $1000 to NZ9 Passengers After Three-Night Delay
- Qatar's Surging Real Estate Prices Won't Affect Thriving Economy – Report
- Manchester United Transfer News: Wilfried Zaha Might Stay After Impressing Van Gaal Against Inter [VIDEO]
- Grimm Season 4 Spoilers: Comic-Con Answers Served, Nick 'Un-Grimmed' Affects His Wesen Friends' Honeymoon
- Transfer News: Ron Vlaar to Consider Villa Exit, May Move to Tottenham
- AS Roma's Seydou Keita Throws Water Bottle at Real Madrid defender Pepe for Spitting [VIDEO]
- The Mentalist Season 7 Spoilers: CBS Skips Simon Baker's Patrick Jane in Fall Schedule, Josie Loren Joins Cast